About Mitford Homes

About Us

Mitford Homes specializes in building affordable, high quality custom homes to elevate the beauty of the neighborhood communities and highlight the enjoyment of custom homeownership.

  • Prices below competition
  • Great service
  • Build 15-20 custom homes per year
  • Economically sound and busy in a slow housing start market
  • Started in 1999
  • Building in Marion and surrounding counties
  • 10 year limited warranty, 1 year full warranty
  • All brick homes
  • Stick-built on-site

Mitford Homes is operated by Paul and Wendy Mitford. Both Paul and Wendy hold Indiana Real Estate Principal Broker licenses, resulting in a better understanding the financial and legal aspects of home building. Mitford Homes build 15-20 custom homes per year in Marion and surrounding counties.

What our customers say about us

My husband and I have built five homes and I have to admit, you were the finest builder I have ever dealt with.
Francine G.
On behalf of me and my family, I'd like to thank Mitford Homes Inc. for doing a fantastic job constructing our house. You build a quality product and have always promptly responded to any of my qestions/concerns. Attention to detail is obvious.
— Dave F.
Being new to the home-building process, Paul and Wendy helped walk us through the process and answered our questions thoroughly and in a timely manner.
— Mr. and Mrs. S.
If building a new home to your own specifications is something you have always dreamed of... please consider speaking with the folks at Mitford Homes.
— Barb G.

Referrals

This program has been introduced for the many Mitford Homes satisfied clients who have friends and associates that would like to build. Simply e-mail Mitford Homes at paulmitford@mitfordhomes.com, include the name and detailed information of your referral. Print out a copy of the email and have the person present it to the Mitford sales associate at the first meeting. If the party signs a contract to build within six months, then $1,000 will be sent to the current Mitford Homeowner upon closing. For second referrals, $1,500 at closing. Third and subsequent referrals $2,000 at closing.

testimonials

I can recall the day in June 2005 when I saw your model home in New Palestine and called to see if we could meet to look at the inside as I really liked the outside of the house. When you agreed to meet with my sister and I and I walked in the front door of that model, I fell in love with it. Since I was making a major move from Arizona to Indiana, I had to find something fast before I had to fly back. I had looked at used and new homes, but I just could not find what I liked, until I saw Yours. Even though it was almost time for me to elave. I rememer you saying, "You could build me anything and anywhere you want it." I left Indiana to return to Arizona and was just no quite sure what I was going to do, but I wanted a home like your model. Read the entire letter.
— Francine G.
My wife and I met Paul Mitford of Mitford Homes one dreary spring day in 2004. We had been looking at homes, new and used, mostly southeast of Indianapolis for a couple of years without any success. We met Paul at one of his models in the Cedar Creek Estates addition in New Palestine. We were immediately impressed by the amenitites that were included in the base price of his homes. Our impression of Paul was also very positive. Read the entire letter.
— Charles M.
Paul,
I could truly sense a high regard for customer service while you are building a home. Not only did you provide excellent communication and feed back with your client you also kept the lender, First Horizon Home Loans, abreast of the progress of the home. It is great to see a builder treat the people they work with as well as you treat your clients. I definitely enjoy working with you and the entire staff of Mitford Homes and hope to do much more business together in the future.
— Mark A. Lewin
Regional Vice President
First Horizon Home Loans
My wife and I had been looking and praying for a house for months. One Sunday afternoon we stopped in New Palestine and saw the house we felt like would be the one for us. It was a Paul Mitford custom built home. Obviously, the first thing we noticed was the design, but secondly we noticed the quality of the construction. Once we talked with the sales person and he provided us with the information on the home, we immediately received the confidence we needed in order to make a final decision to build. We were not necessarily looking to build, but once we saw Paul Mitford's homes and met with him personally, we knew we were in good hands. We had never built a home before, so Paul was patient with us and willing to listen to our nearly daily numerous questions. He always responded quickly, yet never pressured us into making decisions. He also seemd to have a keen sense of knowing what would be best for us. Read the entire letter.
— Mick D.
If building a new home to your own specifications is something you have always dreamed of, but are frightened by the negative stories you have heard, please consider speaking with the folks at Mitford Homes. It was actually a pleasant and fun experience. Read the entire letter.
— Barb G.
We recently built our first custom home with Mitford Homes. Being new to the home-building process, Paul and Wendy helped walk us through the process and answered our questions thoroughly and in a timely manner. The floor plan of our home is open and inviting, better than any of the existing homes we toured. Read the entire letter.
— Mr. & Mrs. S.
Dear Paul:
On behalf of me and my family, I'd like to thank Mitford Homes Inc. for doing a fantastic job constructing our house. You build a quality product and have always promptly responded to any of my questions/concerns. Attention to detail is obvious. Read the entire letter.
— Dave F.